Well, folks. It was fun while it lasted.

As you can see, not much has been happening on this blog lately.

There are several reasons for this, but I will only hit on a couple:

First: It's amazing how much can change in a couple of months--both in our personal lives and on the writing front. A couple of us have signed publishing contracts, and so the need to write, edit, market, promote HAD to take preference over this blog and the services we were providing.

Second: Running this blog, critiquing submissions, providing feedback...well, that's a LOT of dang work. We weren't getting paid for this service. We had a concept and we went with it--for free--not realizing how much time it would involve with very little (nothing) in return for our effort.

Third: Probably the biggest factor that made us come to this decision, was the fact that a good portion of the submissions we received just weren't ready. They needed more revision. We were wanting to give out reviews on AMAZING, fully complete, well edited novels. 90% of what we received didn't come close.

So we've shut it down. We've moved on.

If you liked our comments and our posts, you can check us out on our individual blogs:

Angela Scott: www.whimsywritingandreading.weebly.com or @whimsywriting on twitter or http://www.facebook.com/AngelaScottWriter

D.S. Tracy:

Kacey Mark:

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Rejections Sting, Just Like a Finger Poke to the Eye.

Posted by Ready, Aim, Hook Me at 11:14 PM
 Rejections suck. No one wants them and yet, as writers we’re all bound to receive a few (in most cases, dozens and dozens and dozens). It’s all a part of the “road to publication” process, but nonetheless, they still sting just like a finger poke to the eye.

Rejections suck. Whoops. Did I already say that? Sorry. I hate them. But they do. They really, really do.

I have several rejections under my belt—from contest judges, from agents, from publishing house editors. Even the stupid form rejections hurt, though I shouldn’t take them personally but I do. With each rejection, I’m building a thicker and thicker skin and getting closer to finding the person who will say yes. At least that’s what I keep telling myself. 

Up until last week, when the other two Hook’ers and I started this blog, I’d only been on the receiving end of the rejection stick. Now, I’m in the process of actually delving them out to seasoned and aspiring writers alike.

And I don’t like it one bit.  Not one single bit.

Telling someone that his or her work “just didn’t hook me” isn’t fun at all. In fact, I’ve worried about it a great deal, worried how someone will accept our suggestions and opinions. Because really, that’s all it is—an opinion and you know what they say about opinions (if you don’t, just ask and I’ll tell you).

Here’s the problem: a lot of the submissions we’ve received are actually quite good. Of course, there are a few that are not—some are still in need of additional editing and revisions and read like first drafts. But even though most are good, we’re still rejecting them.

“Why are you Hook’ers rejecting good manuscripts? That’s not fair. That sucks!” you say.  

I agree. It does suck.

But we decided before we started this blog, that a good story just wouldn’t cut it. It couldn’t.


We wanted GREAT stories.

Let me explain why.

First, if we accepted every good story, we’d never write again ourselves. That’s a given. We’d simply be too busy reading and reading and reading and . . . you get the drift. Our own writing goals would be sacrificed and not one of the three of us is willing to do that. We’re writers first, readers second.

Secondly, we want our tag line “2 out of 3 Hook’ers Love My Book!” to really mean something (you probably just rolled your eyes at that, but I’m serious). I’m going to take a moment and be scary honest here. I may even get in trouble for saying this, but here goes . . . there are lots of published books out there on the market with five star reviews they didn’t deserve. (Gasp. I know. Someone is going to throw rotten eggs at me. I sense it coming). Authors trade reviews with other authors—kind of like an “I’ll show you mine if you show me yours” kind of deal. This is a well know practice.  It happens all the time. Is it illegal? Sometimes I wish (I’ve been led astray quite a bit), but no. It’s not. Is it wrong? That’s up to you to decide. Any book with our tagline on it, you will know went through quite a stringent process to receive it and will darn well deserve it.

Even though we’ve set our standard quite high, it doesn’t make sending out rejections any less difficult. We don’t find it fun or pleasurable by any means. All three of us have been on the receiving end of rejections and we know exactly what it is like, and we take this process quite seriously.

Every rejection we send out is done privately. We will NEVER post a bad review on our blog or any other website. Our purpose isn’t to destroy an author. That’s what makes us different from other reviewers—NO PUBLIC HUMILIATION.  And every submission will receive valuable feedback (at least we hope you find it valuable).

If you do receive a rejection from us, please take it with a grain of salt. Remember, we are not professionals and do not profess to be. We’re just three women with very strong opinions. Nothing more.

The greatest piece of advice I can give you is this—Never let anyone tell you that you can’t write. Never let anyone stand in the way of what you love to do. Always keep writing, because out there, somewhere, you have an audience waiting.

(Notice I didn’t say how big that audience was. It could only be one person. It could be millions. If you stop writing, though, you’ll never know).

Angela Scott


christinaggaudet on June 8, 2011 at 6:13 AM said...

I don't think I could ever do what you ladies are doing. Giving people feedback is a lot of work, whether the story is good or bad. I often have a hard time deciding why I feel the way I do about a story. I applaud your efforts!

Patiently waits for her rejection letter.

TL Jeffcoat on June 8, 2011 at 11:15 AM said...

All I can say about this is, when my book is completed and ready for review, that it passes the mustard and I can say "Ya, my book scores Hook'ers.

erica and christy on June 8, 2011 at 6:20 PM said...

Fun! (Not the rejection part, but what you're doing on this blog!) Soon I'll submit to you! Thanks! Glad you tweeted this post! christy

Lyn Midnight on June 8, 2011 at 8:55 PM said...

I agree, actually. ;) I've read books that are HORRIBLE and right now I am recalling one, which had a great idea but was written like crap. Yes, it was a best-seller. Sigh.

I like that idea of yours. I actually got very excited but then I wasn't because I only have half-a-draft and I can submit that! lol

Anyway, I believe you when you say you'll be harsh (not in a mean way but in a critical one), as I've been reading you girls' posts and you're tough. Those winners WILL deserve their badges... :)

RL.Treadway on June 8, 2011 at 9:09 PM said...

I hear you about the review thing, except I'm going to be honest in my *opinions* and if the writer doesn't like it, tough tomato's. I'm just one of many they'll have to thicken their skin on :p

Hildie McQueen on June 9, 2011 at 1:37 PM said...

A stinging opinion is just that, an opinion. Sometimes it hurts,but I'd rather have someone tell me the truth, than to be nice and allow me to continue to make the same mistakes.

RG Hart on June 22, 2011 at 9:59 AM said...

There is a school of thought out there that if half of your readers at a workshop love your work and half hate it then you may have something great.

All of us have opinions based on personal bias. For example, I was at a workshop once where a brilliant story was submitted where a woman was suffering from the effects of rape. I stopped reading the story and said I would never, ever, buy such a story, brilliant writing or not. I still hold this opinion.

I do think what you're doing at this site is a valuable service to us writers and I will be submitting.

Share The Love

Hey! Where Is The Comment Box?

If you can't see a comment box below post, scroll up to the top and click "comments" in the header. *shakes hook'er fist at blog template*

We seem to be having some technical difficulties with commenting. Hopefully, it is just an issue with blogger and it'll be easier in the future. Sorry for the trouble.


Ready, Aim, Hook Me Copyright © 2010 Designed by Ipietoon Blogger Template Sponsored by: Website Templates | Premium Themes. Distributed by: blog template